Related
With recent , massive succeeder such asJoker(2019 ) , andDeadpool(2016 ) , the mirthful Word movie genre has been taken in a whole unlike direction . In the past , gas constant - stag comic Scripture flick have contend to not only make a profit , but also adapt the source material in a way that could please a lot of multitude .
today , it seems as though studios , writer , and directors have finally snap the computer code to make a successful R - rated comic book pic . alas , there were still quite a few box office floating-point operation to ascertain from for get to this point . To search back at some of the diligence ’s skilful and worst over the years , here is our leaning of the 5 best and 5 worst roentgen - rank comic book films according to Rotten Tomatoes .
Worst: The Crow: City of Angels (1996) (12%)
WhileThe Crow(1994 ) starring Brandon Lee is held in very high-pitched regard , its sequel films are n’t nearly as celebrated . regrettably , the second episode of the enfranchisement is considered to be the downright worst R - rate comic book celluloid of all time ( at least concord to Rotten Tomatoes ) . Unlike with the original , The Crow : City of Angelsfails to entrance all of the same action , appearance , and drama of the original photographic film .
Furthermore , very few citizenry from the first film returned for the sequel . Though it makes sense with the lore of the character that a Modern lead would be seen , Alex Proyas did n’t return to direct , with the Book of Job going to Tim Pope alternatively . Though Pope ’s direction is n’t the only thing wrong with the film , it ’s not hard to translate how it is one of the bad comic script movies ever made .
Best: Deadpool (2016) (84%)
For for a while there , it seemed as though theDeadpoolfilm would never be released to audiences . However , after the leak test footage saw a lot of positive feedback , the studio decided to greenlight the undertaking afterall . gratefully , Deadpoolperformed unbelievably well at the box part , even becoming the in high spirits grossing radius - betray celluloid ( domestically ) at the clip .
Not only did the photographic film make a lot of money , but it was very well received by hearing across the world . moreover , both fans of the comics and casual moviegoer were satisfied with the result . ThoughDeadpoolisn’t the highest - rat amusing volume film ever , the character ’s personality and the nature of the cinema make it easy to see why so many enjoyed it .
Worst: Judge Dredd (1995) (17%)
Even an iconic action hero such as Sylvester Stallone was n’t able to makeJudge Dredda good pic . Though the fiber has always been popular on the varlet , he has seemed to struggle on the great sieve . While 2012’sDreddfared much better than the original , it still saw less than stellar critique .
Reboot aside , Judge Dreddis still one of the worst comic book picture show ever made . With a very simple , shallow tale and a lot of natural process , it could be argued that the film is an entertaining vigil . However , it definitely return more into the “ so bad , it ’s good ” type of film .
Best: Hellboy: The Golden Army (2008) (86%)
Thanks to Guillermo del Toro ’s incredible panache , Hellboy was originally brought to the large CRT screen in 2004 . Four years subsequently , actor Ron Perlman and del Toro would deliver once again forHellboy : The Golden Army . Though the first moving-picture show receive high praise , the 2d actually fared much advantageously .
Not only didThe Golden Armyexpand well upon the first , but it narrate an arguably better story as well . moreover , using even more constituent from the comics , The Golden Armymanaged to capture everything that fans love about the character . Though a third film is very likely to never happen , del Toro ’s first two films are unbelievably satisfying for all form of lover .
Worst: Hellboy (2019) (17%)
Guillermo del Toro ’s take on Hellboy is one of the best interpretations of the fictitious character to engagement . With both of his cinema receiving high praise , the 2019 reboot was extremely anticipated , despite being a reboot and not having del Toro sequester .
Unfortunately , the newestHellboyfilm proved to be a full disaster . Not only was it a monolithic dashing hopes at the box place , but it also fail to impress fans . While David Harbour take on the office of the new Hellboy , he did n’t exactly charm what made the part so likeable , making the raw film a full mess of story and over - the - top panel .
Best: Ghost World (2001) (92%)
In comparing to many other films on this list , Ghost Worldis likely not one that people were expecting to see . While the plastic film was liberate in 2001 , the original comedian by Daniel Clowes was published from 1993 - 1997 . Like the movie , the comic also pick up a lot of high praise , making it easy to see why music director Terry Zwigoff wanted to adapt it .
The film also stars a young Scarlett Johansson as Rebecca , one of the motion picture main characters . As the floor of two friends at the end of their gamy schoolhouse careers , Ghost Worldexplores a very unequaled moral force . Though it is n’t like most mirthful Good Book photographic film , it is still a very intriguing watch .
Worst: The Crow: Salvation (2000) (22%)
Though the second may be the spoiled in the serial , The vaporing : Salvationwasn’t much better . After a four year break , the third installment ofThe Crowfranchise was released to the populace , shew to be yet another letdown . Once again , very few multitude involved in the production ofCity of Angelshad anything to do withSalvation . Once again , the mold was entirely dissimilar and manager Bharat Nalluri was fresh to the franchise as well .
Thanks to such a poor functioning from the 2d film , The bragging : Salvationonly saw a limited theatrical release . Most people had to watch it in a straight - to - video data format at the time of its launching . Though it received better review thanCity of Angels , Salvationwasn’t virtually full enough to deliver the franchise .
Best: Logan (2017) (93%)
Logan is unique not only in its relation to other celluloid in the X - Men enfranchisement , but in its human relationship with cinemaa in general . The darker , grittier approach exact in Hugh Jackman ’s last performance as Wolverine really fit well for the role , make him experience much more at home than in some other films .
The film itself did so well that it even received an Academy Award nomination for Best Adapted Screenplay . feature an excellent balance of legal action , heart , and dramatic event , Logan is arguably one of the good comical book films of all clock time . Considering how gamey its musical score on Rotten Tomatoes is as well , it is gentle to see how someone could argue this point .
Worst: Blade Trinity (2004) (26%)
As one of the former superhero franchise , theBladetrilogy proved to be groundbreaking in how it pave the way for other superhero picture show . With a singular portmanteau of action and repugnance , it is perceivable that the trilogy would grow to have a very large cult following . alas , leaf blade : Trinitywould go down in chronicle as one of the tough comic book flick to date .
While the first two installments examine to be rather successful , the third film in the serial publication is simply just not very good . Though there are many other reasons as to why Blade did n’t receive a fourth installation , the radically poor carrying out of the third certainly did n’t help .
Best: American Splendor (2003) (94%)
The originalAmerican Splendorcomics were autobiographic in nature , based on the experience of generator Harvey Pekar . Over the row of several years , Pekar would stay to publish the series , typically with a different creative person from time to time .
When the film adaptation was release in 2003 , it had successfully get by to appropriate a lot of the same themes from Pekar ’s original works . Though it is told in a slightly dissimilar manner , the film still honors the source material , even using it as another chemical element for the story . LikeGhost World , American Splendor is a comic adaption in a different sense , but it is still one of the more unequaled pieces out there .
NEXT : Naruto : Every family relationship Ranked ( & How Long They hold up )
