Avengers: Endgame
retaliator : Endgame ’s reshoots explain why Black Widow ’s destruction was so poorly executed . It was always empty the Avengers would make up a terrible price to undoThanos ' cinch , not least because they needed to retrieve the Soul Stone . In edict to do so , someone would have to sacrifice the mortal they loved the most . Although many fans liked the idea of reckon Captain America and Iron Man school principal toVormir , in truth it was clearly always get to be Hawkeye and Black Widow , the two Avengers with the strongest relationship .
film writer Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely seem to have go through a act of different drafts , and in some of them , it was Hawkeye who sacrificed himself forthe Soul Stone . Several women on the crew object , insist that Black Widow should be the one to demonstrate her heroism and sacrificial love for Clint and his family by assert on dying in his place . It was a curious selection , not least because Marvel is currently function on the much - anticipatedBlack Widowmovie straight after down off the franchise lead . " She has red in her account book and to take her all the way to that sacrifice degree is where her character is headed,“Christopher Markusinsisted . " And to not let her do that seemed a ill turn to her as a hero . "
Related : retaliator : Endgame Utterly Fails Black Widow
Thanos Originally Attacked On Vormir
Speaking at ACE Comic - Con , Jeremy Renner has revealed that the Vormir scenes were part of all-embracing reshoots . The original variation was much more complicated , and involvedThanos launch an plan of attack on Vormirin an attempt to procure the Soul Stone himself . " There ’s an attempt , " Renner recollect , " Thanos is in some ship or something , and a cluster of weird aliens were running around and it was too complicated , so what they did is we shot the panorama , still with the same kind of idea , but now we ’re just fighting each other to devote suicide for the Soul Stone . "
It ’s not hard to derive how this would have fit into the plot of ground ofAvengers : Endgame ; in fact , it ’s still set up in the last theatrical cut . In one scene , Nebula realizes that Thanos bed about the Time Heist , and her first reaction is to attempt to send a message to Black Widow and Hawkeye , warn them . Presumably that act of valor actually imply something originally , with Clint and Natasha forewarned but not quite managing to get tothe Soul Stone before Thanos ' arrival . Thanos ' loyal 2014 version of Nebula may well have assist Clint and Natasha on Vormir , earning their trust and setting up the betrayal more effectively .
It ’s possible this would have also explicate Gamora ’s changing sides a lilliputian more . While a captive , Nebula attempted to discourage Gamora that she would be killed by Thanos in social club to acquire the Soul Stone . Had Gamora been on Vormir as well , she could have come to understand the " soul for a somebody " rule , make water sentiency of her fate .
Related : How The Avengers Secretly go under Up Black Widow ’s Solo Movie
Avengers: Endgame’s Version Was Simpler - But Didn’t Work
Given how many element were potentially in play in the Vormir scene , it ’s no surprise Marvel decided to simplify it a little . But the adaptation they go to was deeply problematic , in tumid part because it only recapitulate the same sort of cycles/second Hawkeye and Black Widow have been in ever since their introduction in the MCU . The two superintendent - spies have only appear together in four Marvel films , and they fight each other in three of them . The one difference this time was that it ended with a dying . The ritual killing is made in a middling arbitrary fashion , in a trash that could well have gone either elbow room , and curiously it ’s unclear how her death fulfills the Soul Stone ’s sacrificial rules . InAvengers : Infinity War , a person involve to choose to give up the one they love for adopt the Soul Stone . InAvengers : Endgame , it ’s plainly that someone you screw has to die , with a self-destruction meet just as well as a ritual killing .
Making thing worse , the symbolisation behind Black Widow ’s death is pretty uncomfortable . harmonise toAvengers : Age of Ultron , Black Widow see to it herself as a monster in bombastic part because as a teenager she allowed herself to be sterilized . That proved to be one of the most controversial discharge inAge of Ultron , even driving author - director Joss Whedon off Twitter for a while , and for good reason ; it finger artificial , a valet de chambre ’s read on what it mean for a cleaning woman to have red in her ledger . Now , inAvengers : Endgame , the woman who can not have a family sacrifices herself for the sake of the Isle of Man who desires to retrieve his .
This simple-minded version also causes elusive legal injury to Nebula ’s narrative . When Nebula wakes up on the priming coat of theTemple of the Power Stone , she realize that Thanos eff , and rather than take flight , she rushes to her fuel pod to send an ( unneeded ) signaling to Black Widow and Hawkeye . The pod is collected by Thanos - but even when she ’s about to be trance , Nebula still does n’t trigger the Pym Particles for get away . presumptively in the original snub , Nebula ’s instincts were correct that Clint and Natasha were in danger , and she stayed around out of courageousness because she refuse to give up them .
Was The Original Version Better?
It ’s light to criticise Marvel for the changes they made toBlack Widow ’s decease scene , which was likely rewrite at amphetamine and accord to Renner was only reshot during additional picture taking six months before the film ’s release . But that does n’t necessarily think of that the Russo brothers made the haywire call ; Renner sounds pretty comfortable with the need to do another take , clearly considering the archetype to be confusing . It may well have been worse viewed in the context of the movie as a whole , turn over the Vormir scenes were intersperse with other time traveling escapade .
Related : Black Widow Can Give Natasha A Legacy ( Without Undoing Endgame )
At heart and soul , though , any rendering of Vormir would have face the same challenge ; how to rationalise Black Widow ’s decease , in both narration and thematic terms . In reality , as soon as Marvel charge to the melodic theme of " a soul for a individual , " either Black Widow or Hawkeye was always belong to break down ; those are the two Avengers whose relationship is strong enough to take into account them to take on the Soul Stone . That was always going to cause all these thematic job , and while another taradiddle may have been a better one , it would have had to face the same issue .
More : How Marvel Phase 4 Will Avoid Avengers Fatigue
