Superbad
word of advice : despoiler ahead forBooksmart
Olivia Wilde ’s directorial debutBooksmarthas fundamentally the same patch as Greg Mottola ’s 2007 movieSuperbad- but it ’s also different enough that the two movie congratulate one another instead of one being the authoritative variant . Booksmartstars Beanie Feldstein ( younger sister ofSuperbad ’s Jonah Hill ) as Molly , an over - achieving school stratum president getting ready to head off to Yale , and Kaitlyn Dever as Amy , a similarly heavily - work introvert who came out as a gay woman for two years , but ca n’t muster up the courageousness to ask out her infatuation , Ryan ( Victoria Ruesga ) .
On the mean solar day before commencement , Molly learns to her horror that everyone in their class managed to get into a good college while also partying their way through high school . Determined that she and Amy are n’t going to fine-tune without having partied , Molly project one dotty night out at a company being throw by their class fellow , Nick ( Mason Gooding ) . There ’s just one problem : they block to get the address of the party .
Related : Every Song In Booksmart
BothBooksmartandSuperbadcome from a grand tradition of teen coming - of - eld movies likeCan’t scarcely WaitandAmerican Pie , in which kid who are on the verge of becoming adults have to face the prospect of moving on to college and leaving the status quo behind - friends included . Booksmarthas pull in a set of comparisons toSuperbad , and its promiscuous to see why . But how like are the two picture , and which one is better ?
Booksmart Basically Has the Same Plot as Superbad
Booksmart ’s Molly and Amy have a standardised dynamic to Superbad ’s Seth ( Jonah Hill ) and Evan ( Michael Cera ) , in that one is bold and plainspoken , whereas the other is quieter and often finds themselves being run around . Also , as inSuperbad , the two eccentric are heading in different instruction after they calibrate : Molly to Yale , and Amy to Columbia after a summer spent help char make tampon in Botswana . And just as Evan save a closed book from Seth so as not to ache his smell ( that he ’ll be room with Fogel at college ) , Amy is keeping a arcanum from Molly - ultimately give away during an argument that she ’s going to Africa for a whole twelvemonth , not just for the summer .
This core character moral force is the heart of both picture show , with the characters ' unexpressed resentment towards one another getting commingle up with the unfeigned angst they ’re feel ( but not really expressing ) about say sayonara to their best friend . For Seth and Evan , this explodes into an disceptation where Seth accuses Evan of " bail " on him by cash in one’s chips to Dartmouth , and Evan accuses Seth of hold him back . For Molly and Amy the fight happens at a political party , with Molly incriminate Amy of never making any bragging decision and having to always be drag out along , and Amy unload the bombshell that she ’s taking a gap year , shake off their college timelines off so they wo n’t graduate at the same clock time .
In bothBooksmartandSuperbadthere ’s a political party to get to , and a knottiness in getting to that political party . For Molly and Amy , it ’s the fact that they do n’t actually know where the party is . For Seth and Evan , it ’s the fact that they ’ve concord to hit strong drink for Jules ' ( Emma Stone ) party , and ca n’t show up empty - handed . It ’s through this obstruction that the hijinks occur - whether it ’s pathetic Fogel getting punched during a booze store robbery , or Molly and Amy undertake to muscle information from a shady pizza rescue guy . In both film the main characters end up go to the wrong company at first , taking them down a route of ridiculous encounters , until they in conclusion get hold of their goal and concisely enjoy a euphoric party experience … until it all goes wrong .
Related : Screen Rant ’s 50 Most hoped-for Movies of 2019
The main characters ' fight is at last resolve , both inBooksmartandSuperbad , by one rescuing the other after the cops raid the political party they ’re at . An extremely drunk Seth carry Evan forth to safety , while Molly shows up the next day to get Amy out of jail so that she can make it to gradation . The two readiness of undecomposed ally apologize to one another ( Seth and Evan while they ’re huddle together on the floor in quiescency bags , Amy and Molly through the glass at the local jail ) , and make peace with the fact that they ’ll presently be split ways .
Superbad and Booksmart Are Great in Different Ways
ThoughBooksmartmay have the same introductory plot social system asSuperbad , it ’s a long way from being a pull - off and both pic are great in their own path . For starters , Booksmartarrived in theater of operations more than a decade afterSuperbad , and as such its teen landscape has a very unlike feel to it . WhereasSuperbadis a classic teenager slacker comedy , Booksmartis an anti - slack motion picture , whose protagonists are high succeeder who already have a ten - year architectural plan for their careers ( or at least Molly does ) . It also subverts the tradition of teen movie high schools being filled with either jocks and burnouts or tyke who are destined for great colleges , by revealing that characters like Nick and " Triple A " ( Molly Gordon ) can both party and get good class .
The fact thatBooksmart ’s admirer are girls also affects the direction they interact . Though there ’s some good - natured teasing between them , like Molly demanding to know which of Amy ’s stuffed toys is more than just a champion , it does n’t take a nighttime of partying and a lot of inebriant for them to be able to say " I love you " to each other . Molly and Amy get their night out by dressing up in match rig and gushing about how beautiful they calculate - something that they restate later after an rig change . And given that so many stripling movie with female friend tend to roll around a makeover game or focalize on romance , it ’s really novel to have a teenager movie that ’s about girls just trying to party and have fun .
All this is to say that whileSuperbadandBooksmartmight share a formula , neither one of them is redundant andBooksmartis not a " rip - off " ofSuperbad . After all , Superbaditself borrowed elements from teen movies that had travel before it , but put its own twisting on them and succeed in stand out . Booksmarttoo adds its own twists , like the hilarious puzzling rich fille Gigi ( Billie Lourd ) who crosses paths with Molly and Amy over and over again on their gaga night out , or a surreal stop - movement episode where Molly and Amy transform into dolls after eating some spikes strawberries .
Related : How To All The Boys I ’ve Loved Before ’s Book Changes Will Impact The continuation
Why Booksmart’s Ending is Better Than Superbad’s
One other major deviation betweenBooksmartandSuperbadis how they end - specifically with respect to whether the protagonists " get the girl " ( or in Molly ’s subject , son ) . Seth and Evan both mishandle their chance at getting with their crushes at Jules ' company , but end up meet up with them at the shopping center the next day and going their disjoined ways . There ’s some poignancy in the moment , butSuperbad ’s ending is believably the least memorable part of the moving picture , and leaves much of the intemperate lifting for Seth and Evan ’s relationship to their belated - Nox confession in the previous scene .
By contrast , neither Amy nor Molly end up getting together with their crush , despite promising sign of the zodiac at the company . Nick flirts with Molly but then leave her to go out to the pond , where he make out with Ryan - much to Amy ’s horror and disappointment . This kicks off the conflict between Molly and Amy and at long last pushes Amy to prove that she ’s not a " Sir Noel Pierce Coward " - first by have a disastrous sexual encounter with Hope ( Diana Silvers ) in the bathroom , and then by saving the respite of the partygoers from the cops by creating a diversion .
There ’s also a muscular scene towards the end ofBooksmartwhere Molly is offered a drive home by her nemesis , a popular and pretty girl who has been given the degrading nickname " Triple A " because of stories about her offer " roadside assistance " to guys ( as Amy luff out earlier in the picture , none of the guys that Triple A got together with were feed degrading nickname ) . The two of them fundament heads at the offset of the movie , with Molly sneering at Triple A for being a loser who peaked in in high spirits school and will fail in biography , before check to her horror that Triple A is also go to Yale . On the drive home , Triple A admits that the worst part of being given her nickname was the fact that girls used it as well of the boys - a sobering moment for Molly , who has posters and car pricker declare herself to be a proud women’s liberationist , but still has a lot to learn about what that means in practise .
Booksmart ’s real culmination is n’t at the company , but the sunrise after , when Molly and Amy go on a wild joy ride in Jared ’s ( Skyler Gisondo ) car and show up to commencement ceremony as heroes . The commencement scene is an eversion of the common " wonk revenge " moving picture chemical formula . Instead of Molly and Amy getting their own back on the presuppose yob , Molly realizes that she ’s been something of a bully herself ; people do n’t dislike her because she ’s smart , but because she face down on them . She reconciles with her classmates , they cheer for her , and its a great feel - upright agency to wrap the movie up . When Amy later decide to show up tardily to her flight so that she and Molly can go and get flannel-cake
finally it ’s toilsome to say , overall , which is the better movie betweenBooksmartandSuperbad . They may keep an eye on the same formula , but they ’re about unlike gender , different generation , and ultimately have very different styles . Booksmartdigs a little deeper , butSuperbadskilfully conveys a dear story about manly friendship within the Trojan horse of a raunchy teen comedy . Booksmartisn’t a copy ofSuperbad- they ’re just two one-half of an first-class double - bill .
More : study Screen Rant ’s Review of Booksmart
