X-Men: Apocalypse
X - Men : Dark Phoenix ’s handsome plot hole literally breaks the entire third turn ofX - humankind : Apocalypse . Fox ’s ten - Men franchise has never just been bed for its consistency . In large part , that ’s because the studio apartment did n’t really do farseeing - terminus provision , instead opting for light - term win .
Unsurprisingly , this has caused major problems for the X - Men franchise over the years . Sometimes it meant they just could n’t figure out how to make a story work ; they ’d been attempting to set up or introduce theclassic baddie Mr. SinistersinceX - Men : First Class , but never quite managed to pull it off . On other occasions , it cause somewhat nightmarish continuity issues . Xavier was killed inX - Men : The Last Stand , outlive by order his mind in another dead body , and yet he was back to normal - complete with disabling hurt - inX - Men : day of Future Past . Wolverine actually lost his claws inThe Wolverine , but mysteriously regained them for the next motion-picture show .
Related : The Complete ten - Men Movie Timeline Explained ( From 2000 To Dark Phoenix )
ButX - Men : Dark Phoenixcontains possibly the most problematic continuity trouble of the entire ten - Men franchise , a plot fix so immense it literally soften the third bit of another movie .
X-Men: Apocalypse’s Third Act Was All About Setting Up Phoenix
The key job is thatX - man : Apocalypse , set up in 1983 , was all about set up the Phoenix Force . The film introducedSophie Turner ’s Jean Greyas a powerful psychic sport , whose ability had been carefully lock down by Xavier so as to help her cope with them . early on on in the motion picture , Jean experienced obsess imaginativeness of the earth consume by fire , visions that she believe were link to Apocalypse . Disturbed by these visions and by the sheer psychic power she was manifesting , Jean spoke of her abilities as though they were almost a separate entity . Xavier disagreed , and attempted to help oneself Jean keep her power in check . In the third enactment , though - faced with the threat of Apocalypse - the Professor had to take a different glide slope . He encouraged Jean to unlock the vast reservoir of near - innumerable psychic powerfulness lie inactive within her , which she loose in ordering to defeat Apocalypse . The get-up-and-go manifest around Jean as a Phoenix raptor effect .
hug drug - man : Apocalypsewas clearly setting up the Phoenix Force , draw off inspiration from mirthful book author Robert Kirkman ’s modernized retelling of the Greco-Roman Phoenix Saga in hisUltimate X - Menrun . That bow saw Jean begin to experience terrifying vision of the world consumed by flak , and her powers expand to a staggering degree . The X - man only learned the truth when they were approached by a religious religious cult , who revealed that Jean was the host of the ancient and cosmic Phoenix Force . They believed the Phoenix to be a raw cosmic military force of creation , restrained in a Brobdingnagian psychic prison millennium ago by fearful races . That prison house had become the Earth , and from its cell the Phoenix had influenced human evolution in purchase order to create the double-dyed host , a being who could contain it and provide it to escape . Jean Grey was the host , her transmitted body structure mutated at conception so as to associate her to the Phoenix Force , manage its straight-out power with ease . Supporting the version that this was intended to serve as the inspiration for the young Phoenix level , the Ultimate interlingual rendition ended with Jean uniting with the Phoenix in conflict with Apocalypse .
The Phoenix reveal is easy the most intelligent part ofX - Men : Apocalypse . Although the Christian Bible " Book of Revelation " has become associated with the idea of the end of the Earth , historically apocalyptical lit was an ancient genre of writing where an angel or godly being revealed the future . Thus the lawful " Book of Revelation " ofX - Men : Apocalypse , in the most ancient mother wit of the Holy Writ , is the revelation that Jean Grey is the Phoenix , with access to the full power of the Phoenix Force .
Related : What Is The Phoenix Force ? The 10 - Men Villain Explained
Dark Phoenix Completely Rewrites The Phoenix Force’s Origins
hug drug - Man : Dark Phoenixcompletely ditches this idea . At the start of the motion-picture show , the Phoenix Force has been cut through the cosmos for untold eons , with entire worlds destroyed in a blaze of Phoenix fervour . The D’Bari homeworld was consume by the Phoenix , and Jessica Chastain ’s fictitious character Vuk is leader of the survivors , who are follow the Phoenix through space for exploit out how to either employ or destroy it . They see their opportunity when Jean Grey encounters the Phoenix while on a mission in space , and she sop up it into herself . The Phoenix triggers further evolution within Jean , who at last becomes one with the Phoenix when she kill Vuk .
This idea is clearly inspire by Chris Claremont and John Byrne ’s original classic " The Dark Phoenix Saga , " where Jean became tied to the Phoenix Force after a standardized missionary post in space - utter with solar flares . But it does n’t fit out at all with the setup . InX - Men : Apocalypse , Jean has accession to the Phoenix back in 1983 ; inX - Men : Dark Phoenix , she gains Phoenix power from an incident in 1992.Even the ocular effects are different , with the Phoenix raptor manifesting as fire inX - man : Apocalypse , but adjusted to give it a more cosmic tone inX - Men : Dark Phoenix . There ’s simply no way to reconcile these two movies .
The X-Men Movies' Final Plot Hole Was Unavoidable
ten - Men : Dark Phoenixis the remnant of the Fox X - Men films , and it ’s a pity the enfranchisement has to end with the big secret plan hole in its total history . In Sojourner Truth , though , this error was largely unavoidable . Fox had already render to adapt the Dark Phoenix Saga once before , in 2006’sX - Men : The Last Stand , and they had fail to squeeze the cosmic side of Claremont and Byrne ’s classical story . Naturally , their second attempt was n’t function to make the same mistake , meaningX - Men : Dark Phoenixwas always go to start with Jean chance the Phoenix for the first sentence .
As was so often the face , the reason for this plot of land mess is simply that Fox failed to plan ahead . They began to set up the Phoenix Force inX - Men : Apocalypse , before they ’d really remember too much about what variant of the Phoenix story they were fail to enjoin . Far from becoming a pad forX - valet : Dark Phoenix , Apocalypsebecame a problem . Fox could either choose to follow it , and tell a essentially different story , or they could just push aside it . They opt for the latter .
More : Dark Phoenix ’s Ending put Up A Final X - Men Movie That Will Never Happen
