The Shining
When it comes to adjustment , few have as testy a kinship as that betweenThe Shiningfilm and the novel . Stephen Kingfamously disagrees with Kubrick ’s imaginativeness , yet both are regarded as some of the best revulsion fable ever make .
WithDoctor Sleep , Mike Flannagan draw a bead on to address the two , creating a continuation that both honored the cinematiclegacyofThe Shining , as well as the peerless work of Stephen King . But , how does the film actuallycompareto its cinematic predecessor ?
Better - Doctor Sleep Isn’t Afraid Of Its Heart
One of the self-aggrandising changes between the book and flick version ofThe Shiningis the excited tone . Like with much of King ’s writing , the novel is far more open with the emotional root word it ’s treatment , making characters far more sympathetic .
Kubrick ’s vision is far colder though , choose a darker and more emotionally detach visual modality . Doctor Sleep combines both and embraces the full range of emotional depth of both of King ’s novels . It is n’t afraid to confront its feelings .
Worse - The Shining Is The Work Of A Master Director
Mike Flannagan has become one of the most exciting theater director work in the repulsion genre today . But , there is no comparison whatsoever to the cinematic bequest pull up stakes behind by Stanley Kubrick . The man craft some of the greatest plastic film of all time and was never confined to a individual genre .
He revolutionized multiple genre and gave audiences some of the most complex and visually gorgeous pieces of cinema ever set up . As great asDoctor Sleepis , it never does anything more than observe that legacy .
Better - Doctor Sleep Explores Different Genres
While Kubrick explored many genres throughout his filmography , The Shiningitself is first and foremost a repugnance film . Doctor Sleep , however , in both the film and novel , explore more than just the revulsion of this story . There are certainly a ton of horror element , with some exceptionally frightening scenes .
But it is also a dark drama about dependance , as well as a road movie . Even some of the supernatural elements are treated less like horror and more like fantasy or science fiction . It is layered and ca n’t be painted into one generic niche .
Worse - The Shining Has Better Performances
Doctor Sleephas a bully plaster bandage to boast . Ewan McGregor does an excellent job as always , and Rebecca Fergusson is one of the ripe interpretations of a King scoundrel in a longsighted time . But there is no denying the masterful performances withinThe Shining .
Jack Nicholson has yet to give a performance more electric and unwieldy than his role as Jack Torrence . But , it is Shelley Duvall as Wendy Torrence who steals the show . Duvall ’s believability as a woman in distress is one of the best in any repulsion film . Even the small supporting cast , bolster up by Scatman Crothers , is exceptional . It ’s no competition , The Shiningis a masterclass in horror move .
Better - Doctor Sleep Is More Connected To Stephen King’s Vision
The Shiningfilm is one of the best revulsion picture of all time . But when it comes to version , it falls to the bottom of the barrel . It is n’t necessarily the fact that it does n’t follow the same events as the book . Look at the recentITadaption , which drastically commute the events of the novel .
That film realize the spirit of the account book , unlike Kubrick ’s film . Doctor Sleepreconciles that fact , crafting a almost - perfect adaption of both of King ’s novels . Flannagan understands the accurate aroused themes that King is grapple within both works , and translates it to screen attractively .
Worse - The Shining Is Scarier
If you compare both films’fright factor , it ’s no contest . WhileDoctor Sleepis full of appall moments and themes , Kubrick’sThe Shiningdelves into a far more glum place . The elements of fear and insanity that it grapples with are second to none .
The cinema also combines Kubrick ’s needlelike directorial heart , crafting visuals that will frequent a viewer more than any mere leap panic attack . It is so aerial in its arranged scare , and the execution only deepen that effect .
Better - Doctor Sleep Had To Jump Over Bigger Hurdles To Succeed
In terms of expectations , Doctor Sleephad far more to show to audiences than Kubrick’sThe Shiningever did . Of of course , there were fan of the original novel who were looking forward to the adaptation , butDoctor Sleephad to gentle decennary of extolment for Kubrick ’s film as well as King ’s two novel .
make a sequel to both of those , let alone an adaption of a sperate novel is no gentle job . YetDoctor Sleepsucceeds in all of this , while still being a fascinatingly able film of its own . It doubles as a work of Flannagan ’s , Kubrick ’s , and King ’s imaginations .
Worse - The Shining Has More Impressive Shot Composition
There is no doubt in the fact that Mike Flannagan has a definite ocular aesthetical . His color palette and shot make-up are wholly his own . The fact that it is so solid is certainly a plus . But , as stated earlier , it has nothing on the cinematic optic mind of Stanley Kubrick .
There is not a single shot throughoutThe Shiningthat could n’t be analyzed to decease . Every second of the film is meticulously map out . Everything from the set aim , block , lighting , and color palette serves a role unlike any other film out there ( apart from anything else of Kubrick ’s ) .
Better - Doctor Sleep Is More Accessible
The narrative style and filmmaking proficiency of The Shining are unmatched , but they are also nowhere near as accessible as Mike Flannagan ’s . Flannagan is a masterful modern music director , but he is anything but ostentatious . He makes repulsion for just about everyone and does so without any hint of sell out . This is not to say that his films are cheap or shallow . In fact , most are the exact opposite . But nearly anyone can get something out of a Mike Flannagan repulsion film .
Worse - The Shining Doesn’t Pander To Audiences
On the other hand , Stanley Kubrick ’s moving picture , along with most of his work , decline to pander to audiences . It chooses the far more subtle route , leaving matter unanswered an up for interpretation . There are so many sequences throughout where you never know what is real and what is n’t . That is n’t even the point , in fact . Kubrick is far more concerned with how these successiveness will make you feel on their own and it is far more pure as a piece of cinema in that regard .
NEXT : Doctor Sleep : 10 Scariest consequence From The Stephen King Movie
