Avengers: Endgame
WARNING : Major spoiler forAvengers : Endgame .
-
Many are have a punishing enough time understandingAvengers : Endgame ’s prison term travelling rules and logic , and it turns out not even the film ’s writers and manager agree on how it works . Even though a bulk ofAvengers : Endgame ’s story revolve around sentence travel , the explanation for how it work really comes down to two scenes in the movie . When the team is first figuring out how they can do it , Hulk explain that they can not change their own pasts by going back in prison term . The Ancient One later explain during one of their clip travel missions that they must also fix any change done during their travel ( like taking Infinity Stones ) , otherwise offset realities would be make .
At the very end ofAvengers : Endgame , Captain America is prefer to travel through time again andreturn the Infinity Stonesat the exact import they were taken , guaranteeing that realness would continue the same . His job is to clip all the branches ( including take back Mjolnir to 2013 Asgard ) , but instead of return to 2023 when the chore is finish , he detain in the past to produce old with Peggy Carter . He isseen in 2023as an old gentleman , and directors Anthony and Joe Russo previously explicate that this is becausehe riposte from a forked realism .
Related : Why Captain America ’s Avengers : Endgame Ending Is n’t A Plot Hole
Even though this was widely accepted to be the showcase , many devotee also wondered if there was a chance that Cap farm old with Peggy in the main timeline all along . This would go against the Russo brothers ' account of the events , but it turns out thatAvengers : Endgamewriters Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely do n’t agree with them . As Markus revealed in a Q&A withFandango , they believe that Steve ’s action did not create a new timeline because of the specific of The Ancient One ’s account .
That is our hypothesis . We are not expert on time travel , but the Ancient One specifically states that when you take an Infinity Stone out of a timeline it creates a fresh timeline . So Steve going back and just being there would not create a new timeline . So I reject the " Steve is in an alternate realness " hypothesis .
I do believe that there is simply a period in mankind history from about ' 48 to now where there are two Steve Rogers . And anyway , for a large chunk of that one of them is frozen in ice . So it ’s not like they ’d be run into each other .
The Russo brother have a great working kinship with Markus and McFeely and are usually always on the same page when it come to explaining what bump in their films . That is what makes this take issue mindset all the more surprising , and reasonably confusing . The writers do accept that they are n’t experts on prison term travelling and that this is just their interpretation , but could it really make gumption for the MCU to have 2023 Steve Rogers around through all the events since around 1948 ?
Such an account would entail thatAvengers : Endgameis squeeze the linear timeline with time loops explanation of time travel , where you are n’t change the past but enable something that already did take place . This would potentially allow Steve to live a normal life sentence for the last 80 yr of the MCU that we ’ve never find out , lay down him the married man that Peggy ’s referred to in the past tense but never identify . This account also means that only changes to the Infinity Stones would create branched realities , while returning Mjolnir could be an expansion on this idea , and Cap going to the past does n’t make one because it already happened .
After appear to have clarity on what Steve ’s ending inAvengers : Endgamemeans , we are now back to lame one with two vie explanations . Since both the Russo brother and Markus and McFeely are done with the MCU for the fourth dimension being , it may be left up to next MCU stories to in reality explicate what the in - canon explanation is , but the closing of Cap ’s story still works on an emotional level no matter what is decided .
MORE : Our 22 Biggest Unanswered Questions After Avengers : Endgame
Source : Fandango
