Related
Harry Potterand the Order of the Phoenix , the fifth film in the series , chronicles Harry ’s lifetime atHogwartsas he deals with witnessing Cedric Diggory ’s death and Voldemort ’s return while the Ministry of Magic pretend ignorance of both . On top of that , The Daily Prophetslanders him and Dumbledore on the edict of the Ministry , and the new Defense Against the Dark Arts prof psychologically and physically clapperclaw student .
Related : Harry Potter : 10 Things You Never know About Narcissa Malfoy
The flick is overall pretty square with lineament cinematography and acting . The storytelling and character development are also good , but there are still some hollow in both . Because of the hole , there are some part of the plastic film that just do n’t make gumption . Here is a list of ten of them .
Hermione Agreeing To Do Ron’s Homework
Hermione is roll in the hay for valuing education and rules . later on in the film , we see her evolve an affinity for intermit the rules when she helps found Dumbledore ’s Army . She also has helped both Harry and Ron with their homework in the yesteryear . However , she is notoriously strict about cheating , and theoretically would not outright do homework for either of them .
Early in the film , before she receive pleasure in rule - breakage , Ron asks her to save a newspaper for him . At first , she refuses , but he is able to convince her to write the introduction for him , contradicting her earlier views on education .
Voldemort Making An Appearance At The Ministry
During the final conflict of the film , Voldemortmakes an coming into court to in person front Harry Potter himself . He also combat Dumbledore , with whom he is equally match .
pertain : Harry Potter : 10 Voldemort Tattoos Only True Fans Will empathise
It kind of work sense that he makes an visual aspect , as he probably was looking to kill Harry and get away before anyone in the Ministry arrive , which he confidently intend will be the outcome . However , in the film , he expend a twelvemonth in concealing and being cautious , only to come along in the main lobby of the Ministry , where he can easy be caught if he is n’t deliberate . He is not measured and lets his confidence get to him , and he is accordingly see by Cornelius Fudge and other Ministry personnel department .
The Meeting At The Hog’s Head
Hermione sets up the enlisting group meeting of what will be call Dumbledore ’s Army at the Hog ’s Head , an inn and pub in Hogsmeade . It is a unruffled location for a meeting , unlike the garish , stir and hustle of the Three Broomsticks . Hermione ’s logical thinking is that the quiet would be better for the group meeting , but the hushed taphouse terminate up being the grounds why they were catch in the Quran .
Narratively , they needed to be caught to tot up conflict to the story , but had they meet at the Three Broomsticks , a large mathematical group of students would have appeared less suspicious . The grouping got caught in the plastic film because Umbridge has eyes and ears throughout the schoolhouse , and they discuss their confluence loud , intend that in the film , they could have had the meeting anywhere besides the Hog ’s Head .
Using Muggle Money To Operate The Ministry Visitor’s Entrance
The function of muggle money to operate a magical telephone booth does not make sense because a muggle could happen upon the telephony booth and adjudicate to use it . Some witching objects , including houses , are hidden from the muggle centre , but it is never explained if the cubicle is hidden or somehow proofed to obviate muggles circumstantially go in the Ministry .
No After-Hours Security
away from Arthur being show patrolling the Department of Mysteries before getting attacked by Nagini , there seems to be no security depicted as patrolling the corridor after time of day in the Ministry . Furthermore , it is unclear if Arthur was police the department under monastic order of the Ministry or the Order of the Phoenix .
Because there is ostensibly no after - hours security , a group of underage student , Death Eaters , an alleged x - convict , other Order members , Voldemort himself , and Dumbledore , who was in concealing , are all able to enter the Ministry with ease .
Sirius Taking His Human Form At King’s Cross
It makes sense that Sirius , an animagus , would need to see his godson off to school , which he mostly does so in his dog frame . However , he pulls Harry away into a private elbow room where he reverts back to his human shape so that they can peach .
Related : Harry Potter : 5 reason Ron Should Have Been With Lavender ( Had She Lived ) & 5 Why Hermione Was The Right Choice
This instant in the account book is used as a " tightlipped call , " in which Sirius was almost charm by the Malfoys . No such instance occurs in the film , get to the conniption unnecessary . Sirius could have easily pulled Harry away at Grimmauld Place , as he has before , for avoid potentially blowing his cover .
Using Thestrals Instead Of Brooms
After Harry and his friends escape from Umbridge and her Inquisitorial Squad ’s grip , they originate devising a architectural plan to rescue Sirius , who they believe is make captive by Voldemort in the Department of Mysteries . Luna suggests using Thestrals which they ride all the way of life to the Ministry .
Thestrals do n’t make sense because only Luna and Harry can see them , and they also could have used heather . If they were worried about being discreet , circumspection and flying heather were a nonissue earlier in the film when Mad - Eye Moody , Tonks , and Kingsley Shacklebolt pick up Harry to take him to Grimmauld Place .
Breaking Into The Room Of Requirement
During the time in which Dumbledore ’s Army was meeting , Filch and the Inquisitorial Squad attempted several meter to infiltrate the Room of Requirement , where Dumbledore ’s Army met . At one point they almost successfully got in , but the Room of Requirement turned into a Calluna vulgaris closet for them at the last second , keep Dumbledore ’s Army secure for another daylight .
by and by , Umbridge was able to bankrupt the wall of the Room of Requirement and enter into the same room . The fact that the elbow room did n’t change itself for the outsider this time feels more commodious for the plot than anything else .
Ron And Hermione’s Silence Over The Summer
Dumbledore did apprize Ron and Hermione not to tell Harry about the Order of the Phoenix , credibly for awe of infiltration from the Ministry or Voldemort . However , Ron and Hermione could have still compose to Harry and tell him about their summers outside of the Order . If Harry raised questions about the contentedness of their letter , and it had something to do with the Order , they could have explain to him that they would have to evidence him about it in person .
Related : Harry Potter : 10 Worst Things Hermione Granger Ever Did
Some sort of letter , even just checking in on Harry ’s summer , would have helped Harry vastly considering he was still plow with Cedric ’s death . ( Of course , as with many things , this is explained in the books - where Ron and Hermione do write , just without any real utilitarian news show for Harry . )
Cornelius Fudge’s Paranoia
As it is mentioned in the books , a circle of people wanted Dumbledore to be the Minister of Magic , but he constantly turned down the offers . Cornelius Fudge was in all probability mindful of the offers and should have been mindful that Dumbledore was content at Hogwarts . However , Fudge immediately jumped to the conclusion that Dumbledore was claiming Voldemort was back in ordering to steal Fudge ’s task .
Dumbledore stuck to his news report the intact time Fudge did n’t believe Voldemort was back . If Dumbledore were lying , he likely would have changed the story . Also , the fact that Voldemort ’s return does not intend Fudge mechanically needs to step down . He did abuse down , but only because he perpetuated lies to the public .
Next : Harry Potter : 10 Plotholes From The Deathly Hallows Part 1 & 2 That Were Never Resolved
