Related
It ’s somewhat easy to see that Sybill Trelawney , the eccentric and over - striking prof of Divination was not a great teacher . All the other teacher seem to discover her thwarting at best , and she hides away in her tug to keep out from them . Headmaster Albus Dumbledore mostly have her the stance to protect her after she made the forecasting that led Voldemort to killHarry Potter’sparents .
Trelawney does have some moments when her predictions come true . But she mostly capitalizes on the force of proposition , wispy statements , and sophistication . Here are ten fourth dimension those trend could have gotten her fired .
Emotional Outbursts
No one would ever call Trelawney calm . She is given to dramatic event and makes predictions of misfortune as easily as other masses suspire . InOrder of the Phoenix , when she is being harassed by Dolores Umbridge , Trelawney reacts poorly to the evaluation . Nearlyevery teacher hates Umbridge ’s hindrance , but Trelawney seems to be the only one that read it out on her bookman .
Not Understanding What She’s Seeing
InPrisoner of Azkaban , we ’re enter to the Grim , a jumbo spiritual dog that foretell last . Almost every shaver who arise up in the Wizarding World seems to believe in it .
When Trelawney see a dog in Harry ’s teacup , she claims it is the Grim . course , this is another prediction of Harry ’s tragical and untimely decease . It ’s disputable , however , that the dog in Harry ’s loving cup is a anticipation of Sirius Black ’s entrance to his life . Sirius ’ Animagus form is a giant black dog , and he uses that form to take to the woods Azkaban and get onto Hogwarts grounds . Trelawney is see the futurity but she does n’t understand it at all .
Making Vague Threats
InGoblet of Fire , Trelawney seems to take special delight in predicting something irritating for Harry in every class . Professor McGonagall and Dumbledore both assure him that this is something Trelawney savour doing with many bookman . But yield Harry ’s repute in the Wizarding World , it ’s loose for her to capitalise on him to impress everyone .
Of naturally , keep her threats wispy entail that she ’s always going be technically right . order Harry that there are “ difficult times forwards ” could mean anything from struggling through schoolhouse designation to press Voldemort . Of course , he does both in his fourth year .
Manipulating Students
Trelawney often uses her “ talent ” to reach ends . She in particular uses Neville ’s anxiousness against him , as she does in his very first stratum . Seeming Neville ’s ineptitude , she “ predicts ” that he ’ll break a cup , which of course became a self - fulfilling divination .
She trades on that again during final examination . Naturally , her finish is that the students do n’t cheat by telling each other about the net . But recreate on Neville ’s unwieldy anxiety is a cruel way to do it .
Planting Seeds Of Doubt
In her profile of Trelawney , JK Rowling wrotethat Trelawney loves impressing fleeceable students with predictions of day of reckoning and disaster . As with all false foretelling , these sort of “ prediction ” sour best when they ’re preserve vague . While sometimes she trade on the force of prompting , make a vague threat with a deadline plants a seed of doubt .
It ’s only natural that Lavender would do the work for her . Despite the fact that her coney does n’t actually go bad on the 16th , Lavender consider the foretelling fulfilled . And that ’s all it takes for her to cement Lavender ’s organized religion .
Capitalizing On Fear
Once again , Trelawney capitalizes on Neville ’s nervousness for one of her “ predictions . ” As an adult who had survived the first Wizarding War against Voldemort , Trelawney would know who Neville Longbottom ’s parents were . Both were excruciate until they were insane . After that , Neville grow up with his grandmother , his only remaining family . Trelawney ask after his grandmother , bonk Neville would fear desperately recede her as well .
Insulting Other Teachers
For the most part , Professor Trelawney keeps to herself . She seldom descends to join the rest of the school because she claims it clouds her Inner Eye . It could also be because she realizes that the other teachers are more competent than she is and do n’t take her seriously .
As far as we know , however , none of the other instructor insult each other to the pupil . Trelawney and Firenze , a centaur Dumbledore hires after Umbridge fires Trelawney , have a rivalry that conduct to them insulting one another in front of student . He calls her work “ human nonsense , ” and Trelawney deoxidise him to a buck in front of a student .
Shouting At Dumbledore
Everyone has work disputes . No job is perfect . But shouting at your boss seldom goes well . Trelawney , however , in her fury about Firenze persist at the castling in Half - Blood Prince , seems to pick engagement with Dumbledore legion times . She wish well for Firenze to be discharge , and does n’t seem to understand ( or maybe simply does n’t care ) that to terminate him would be to excoriate him to death .
From what she said to Luna , this does n’t seem like the only time Trelawney has had this conflict . No wonder Dumbledore , who normally remains serene , is “ exasperated ” by her .
“Predicting” The Deaths Of Students
harmonize to McGonagall , Trelawney predicts a student ’s end every year and it has never do to go through . But that does n’t stop her from doing it anyway . Given that she is always latching onto students who are already flighty or believers ( Neville , Lavender , Parvati ) , this is a disturbing habit of hers .
sure there ’s some rule that even if a SeerdoesSee death for a educatee , she should protect that tike from it ? Someone call in Dumbledore on this one , it ’s a really vicious thing for her to keep doing .
Her Drinking Problem
Multiple time when Harry meets her , Trelawney reek of sherry . When she address to Luna in Half - Blood Prince , Trelawney responds with “ an wild , bibulous titter . ”Rowling writesthat Trelawney “ develop an over - trust on alcoholic beverage ” due to her perceived ill - treatment .
Alcoholism is an addiction and should be treated as an illness , not a role defect . However , Trelawney seems to often be drunkin front of students . She lives in Hogwarts Castle and should be upholding decorousness for the students . As a prof , she is suppose to be a drawing card for the student . intoxicated at study is not a great example .
NEXT:10 Harry Potter Tattoos Only True Fans Will Understand
