Related
WhenHarry Potterfans intend of Professor Minerva McGonagall , the matter that comes to mind is a strong - willed and fearless loss leader at Hogwarts . McGonagall is a no - nonsense yet empathetic adult design in the wizarding public whose accomplishments proceed her . She is one of the most extremely regarded witches in their realm and works predominantly to see that Harry and his friends bring home the bacon .
Despite her good - natured sense , there are a few things that McGonagall has done that are questionable . While the steps that she takes is undeniably done in good faith , sometimes her moves make obstacle , either in Harry ’s life sentence directly or towards Hogwarts as a whole . Here are the 10 bad things that McGonagall has ever done .
She Sends Students Into The Forbidden Forest
After Draco view Harry , Ron , and Hermione sneaking off to confabulate Hagrid , he go to Professor McGonagall to rat them out . She call in them into her office staff for reinforce their punishment . And , unlike normal schools , McGonagall saw it tally to station five 11 - year - olds into what had been established as theForbiddenForest to answer detention . This seems like a harsh sentence , specially by McGonagall ’s standards . Then again , maybe she saw it as an opportunity for them . She is quite ferocious .
She Let Gilderoy Lockhart Make Decisions
clearly , it would be hard to support Gilderoy Lockhart as a teacher and Dumbledore ’s decision to hire him if McGonagall were to keep stepping on his toe . Both in the book and in the movies , it is light that McGonagall has a sure antipathy for the eccentric prof who audiences later pick up to be a imposter . Despite knowing this from the kickoff , McGonagall routinely allows Lockhart to make decision . This seems like a huge oversight peculiarly considering it always involves the student . From fixing Harry ’s wiped out weapon to egging him on about his delusion about the Chamber of Secrets , the good affair she could have done was to call him out on his lies .
Not Sending Students Home After The Chamber of Secrets
Although this was her initial instinct , McGonagall end up not sending students home after the Chamber of Secrets is revealed to have been opened . Even after Dumbledore ’s suspension , when she require over as irregular Headmistress of Hogwarts , McGonagall still did n’t make the decision to send students home . Students were being Petrified remaining and correct with no noesis of how or why it is take place . Hogwarts is consider to be a safe plaza , so perhaps this is her abstract thought , but , ultimately , considering the safety of the students , McGonagall should have seen it set to send them home until the issue was resolved
She Didn’t Let Harry Go To Hogsmeade
One of the most devoid , yet heart0breaking moments fromHarry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkabanis when McGonagall does n’t appropriate Harry to go to Hogsmeade . Hogwarts students can only go to Hogsmeade after their third year and with a signalize permit faux pas . Even though she is well aware of the Dursley ’s and Harry ’s living situation , she holds fast to the rule .
Harry see McGonagall as a fond parental human body , so he brings the slip to her in hopes that she can sign it for him . It ’s a notification and touching motion , yet she tells him that ca n’t revel this little getaway with his friends , since it ’s the Dursley ’s that involve to signalise his slip . It ’s a tough - love moment , but it ’s really sad to see after all Harry has been through .
She Tells Students About The Chamber of Secrets
Readers know that it was Professor Binns , the History of Magic teacher , that actually tells scholarly person about the Chamber of Secrets , but for the aggregative majority of people who have only seen the flick , it ’s McGonagall who reveals its story . This seems like something that should not have been explain in the thick of a dire site .
confessedly , McGonagall is hesitating at first , but she in the end decides to tell apart a class full of 12 and 13 - year - old how their lives were in jeopardy . It does n’t seem like a smart move on her remainder , but this noesis does help Harry solve the dilemma in the end .
She Gives Hermione A Time Turner
The Time - Turner is a very sensible bit of charming equipment that even the most experienced witches and wizards have not been entrusted with . It seems strange that McGonagall allows a 13 - year - old to apply it so as to get to two redundant class . It also seems like this move is condoning an unhealthy behavior . Hermione is a bit over - the - top when it come to her education , and while it ’s an good-humoured quality to have , McGonagall should n’t have allowed Hermione to exploit herself as she did , especially when the only way to do this is by handing over an extremely powerful piece of magic .
She Belittles Professor Trelawney’s Profession
Again , McGonagall is a no - nonsensicality kind of mortal , but she really should have known when to burn her tongue . She shows immense constraint when follow to the Dolores Umbridge and her overtaking of Hogwarts , but , inHarry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban , McGonagall openly denigrate the Divination teacher ’s profession .
It ’s very clear to Harry and the other scholar that McGonagall , who comes extremely respected in the wizarding world , does not believe in or endorse her workfellow ’s professing . This is n’t something a instructor should admit to , especially to her students . But , as it turns out , it ’s Trelawney ’s prophecy that acts as the axis for the events of the wizarding world , so McGonagall may have learn to be more heart-to-heart - minded .
The Time She Challenged Aurors
During O.W.L exam , Umbridge sends a team of Aurors to evict Hagrid from Hogwarts . McGonagall , who has respect for him , buy the farm to intervene and starts yelling at the Aurors to go away . However , the Aurors take her threat seriously , and they hit her with four stunning spells . The shock is so severe that she has to go to St. Mungo ’s Hospital for treatment , bequeath Umbridge to be the only prof in charge of Hogwarts .
Obviously , McGonagall could n’t have recognise that the Aurors would react this way , but it seems strange that she becomes erratic weigh she ’s fairly sound . Had she not reacted to the post so turbulently , pupil would not have been left at Hogwarts defenseless against Umbridge ’s scourge .
Letting Snape Pass
She Encourages Students To Fight In The War
As things are coming to a head , and the accelerator for the Second Wizarding World War make its mark , McGonagall serve on the front line . She is on the dot the type of mortal Harry and the students of Hogwarts take to be leading the rebellion . In the book , Pansy Parkinson make believe a remark telling McGonagall that perhaps they should give into Voldemort ’s whims and surrender Harry .
At this point , McGonagall distinguish the scholar that anyone who does n’t wish to fight can leave . The younger pupil have already made their way of life out through the hugger-mugger tunnels into Hogsmeade , but the residue she encourages to stay and fight . This seems like a unusual tactic , no matter how necessary it is at the time , to provide teenagers to put up a fight against a massive grouping of serial slayer .
NEXT : Harry Potter : 10 Facts About Harry leave Out Of The Movies
