Related
When Disney first bought Lucasfilm from George Lucas and a mess of newStar Warsmovies were announce , diehard fans were sceptical . Lucas had alwaysplanned to makeStar Warsa nine - movie saga , starting with the original trilogy , preserve through the prequel trilogy , and conclude with the sequel trilogy .
TheStar Warscreator had written story outlines for each installment in the sequel trilogy , but Disney scrapped them in favor of start from scratch . As it turned out , “ starting from abrasion ” just meantrehashing the original trilogy . So , here are 10 Main Differences Between Disney’sStar WarsSequel Trilogy And George Lucas ’ Treatments .
Younger heroes
The heroes in Disney ’s trilogy are more or less the same age that Luke , Han , and Leia were in the original trilogy . However , in Lucas ’ treatments , the heroes were teenagers .
You might be marvel why Lucas wanted to plunk back into that sphere when he already test making kid the hoagy inThe Phantom Menacewith an 8 - year - honest-to-goodness Anakin and a 14 - year - old Padme , andit did n’t really work out . But then again , Lucas is the brilliant brain that createdStar Warsin the first place , so we also have to desire that he knew what he was doing with his own saga .
Luke would’ve been younger, too
Whenever George Lucas talks about Disney’sStar Warssequels , he seems pretty miff that they did n’t stick to his vision for the story : “ All the path back to – with the Force and the Jedi and everything – the whole construct of how thing go on was laid out completely from [ the beginning ] to the final stage . But I never get to finish . I never got to tell people about it . ”
As we view from the fan response to the prequels , Lucas - helmedStar Warsmoviescan prove to be just as factious as ones directed by J.J. Abrams or Rian Johnson . According to George Lucas biographer Dale Pollock , the sequels would ’ve involved “ Luke Skywalker in his thirty and 40s . ” Disney could n’t really help this , since Mark Hamill is an aging human being andthey did n’t buyStar Warsuntil 2012 .
Luke had a love interest
In Lucas ’ variant of the sequel trilogy , Luke Skywalker had fall in love and had a distaff romantic mate . However , sincethe prequel trilogy established that the Jedi are celibate , this was drop . Still , Mark Hamill did confirm recently that inThe Last Jedi , Luke did n’t die a virgin .
Maybe because the Jedi Order has n’t formally existed since Palpatine executed Order 66 inEpisode III , the surviving Jedi Knights – i.e. Luke , Obi - Wan , possibly Rey , andmaybe a duet of others – could peck and choose which dominion they survey . The judicial eubstance keep them celibate does n’t exist anymore , so why bother ?
Luke’s Jedi Temple was shaped like a bell
George Lucas has criticized Disney ’s decision to makeThe Force Awakensmore “ retro ” than forward - thinking like his original trilogy and even the prequels did : “ They wanted to do a retro picture . I do n’t like that . Every flick , I solve very hard to make them totally different , with dissimilar planets , with unlike spaceships , make it new . ”
He wasloosely involved in Disney ’s earliest ontogenesis of the sequel trilogy , okay some construct artistry . He approve a pattern for Luke ’s temple that was afterward changed when Rian Johnson was brought on panel . VFX art director James Clyne excuse , “ This art was shown to George Lucas in a presentation . Doug [ Chiang , Lucasfilm executive creative director ] came back and said , ‘ Congratulations , James . You got a George “ Fabulouso ” stamp . ’ ”
R2-D2 and C-3PO were the only characters to appear in every single movie
WhileThe Rise of Skywalkerwill likely thoroughgoing Lucas ’ vision of a nine - moving-picture show saga in which R2 - D2 and C-3PO are the only characters to appear in every installing . That was one of Lucas ’ judicial admission with the rules ofStar Wars .
Disney did n’t honor the obligatory coming into court of R2 - D2 and C-3PO withSolo , although they did withRogue One , and it attend as though they ’ve at least made sure that the two droids appear in every cinema in the Skywalker saga . It ’s not clear ifC-3PO have a red ink armwas one of Lucas ’ ideas or a ploy by Disney to sell twice as many C-3PO toys ( the one with the red arm and the one without the crimson weapon system ) .
Leia’s Force sensitivity
It ’s widely love that Lucas wanted to show Leia using the Force in the sequel trilogy , sinceReturn of the Jedihad break her to be a Skywalker and he want toconfirm her Force sensitiveness . Lucas felt it would be a “ waste of natural gift ” if there was n’t a tantrum in which Leia used the Force , so he qualify it in the treatment .
However , it ’s unknown if his version of events had Leia flying around the abstruse vacuum of spacelike she ’d suddenly become Mary Poppins . The problem with that scene was that it madethe established mythology of the Forceimmediately inconsistent .
Luke trained Leia and died one movie later
InThe Last Jedi , the center chapter of Disney ’s trilogy , we see Leia divulge her Force abilities shortly before Luke bites the dust . According to Mark Hamill , Lucas ’ tale treatments for the continuation trilogy did n’t kill off Luke until the very end ofEpisode IX – the very end of the Skywalker saga , which makes sense – and while he stuck around for longer , he used the extra prison term to trail Leia to command her Force sensitivity and finally master it .
Hamill explained , “ I pass to sleep with that George did n’t kill Luke until the remainder of [ Episode]IX , after he trained Leia . ”
Palpatine didn’t appear untilEpisode IX
George Lucas was work on storyline for the sequel trilogy before he even finished the original trilogy . Before makingReturn of the Jedi , Lucas planned to include the first appearance of Emperor Palpatine , as well as Luke ’s face-off with him , inEpisode IX .
The moments were at long last both included inJedi , but Disney might still follow this plan withthe surprisal reappearance of the EmperorinThe Rise of Skywalker . Perhaps Rey will take Luke ’s shoes in the original version of theEpisode IXplot . J.J. Abrams reportedly met with George Lucas to get his approving on the script , so it ’s altogether potential .
Luke was introduced earlier
The sequel trilogy kept the fact that Luke Skywalker had exile himself to Ahch - To , place of the first Jedi Temple , after trying totrain the next generation of Jediand being betrayed by his evil apprentice / nephew Ben Solo . So , all of that Luke plot line , whichhas been criticized as uncharacteristic , was actually in Lucas ’ former treatments .
The difference is that instead of wait until the very end ofEpisode VIIto reveal him , Lucas would ’ve play in Luke much earlier . A young loyalist named Kira ( who was later renamed Rey ) would find him and become the pharos of promise that keeps him pass as he trained her in the ways of the Force . It was in the portrayal of this of the essence character ontogenesis thatThe Last Jedistumbled .
Explaining the universe
According to George Lucas , his sequel trilogy would ’ve gotten really trippy in explain the cosmos : “ [ The next threeStar Warsfilms ] were go to get into a microbiotic world . But there ’s this globe of creatures that operate differently than we do . I call them the Whills . Andthe Whills are the ones who really control the universe of discourse . They fee off the Force . ”
As many rooter experience , Star Warswas in the beginning titledJournal of the Whills , so this was clearly Lucas ’ vision from the root . However , despite the fact it was drop a line years before , it ’s a little close towhat the MCU is doing with the Quantum Realm .
NEXT:10 Star Wars Moments That Could ante up Off In The Rise Of Skywalker
