Twilight
As powerful and impressive as theTwilightfranchise phenomenon has prove to be , no one can traverse that the series has its problems , both in film and book of account chassis . It has been laugh at for consume a bland " Mary Sue " as its friend as well as for being speckled with scurrilous behavior between teens that should in no way be the # relationshipgoals as they are routinely celebrated as by fans . The teens of the serial publication still need a lot of practice session when it make out to managing a healthy human relationship , despite the fact that several of them really are n’t teens anymore given their actual historic period .
If any of the match in the series seem as if they truly have it all together as an example of a self-colored , level-headed kinship , it has to be Carlisle and Esme Cullen , the kinsfolk paterfamilias and matriarch . Carlisle is known as the compassionate town physician , and his wife is perchance the kindest person in Forks , let alone her coven . The two have belong well beyond their accord to only be vegetarian vampires , refusing to dine on human beings , and strive to amend their community and family as well . Even so , these two still have the issue that we have to pull a face over , from their doctor - patient role status to the questions about them that are never really answered in the serial .
From their unconventional meeting to their unearthly decisions as a duo , here areTwilight : 25 thing That Make No Sense About Carlise And Esme Cullen ’s Relationship .
He’s A Doctor Who Married His Patient
In many circles , a doctor conjoin a patient would be considered taboo at the very least . human relationship with big businessman imbalances can be particularly harmful , and lines string to keep personal and professional matters freestanding exist for a rationality . Many people in power might take advantage of their position in ordination to acquire the upper hand over a patient , while patients themselves might simply be after a productive and powerful person .
Many might indicate that this marriage transcends the normal boundaries of Dr. - patient role borderline , but it does n’t change the fact that he is a doctor who married his own patient .
They Settled In An Area With Werewolves
If you ’re a family line of vampires attempting to keep a low-toned visibility , it stand up to reason that you would research an arena heavily before wee program to conciliate down there . The fact that the Cullens decided to live in Forks with the figure - shifting Quileute tribe already living there seems rather dazed .
Even with the truce between them on the table , the fact that the ill will between the kindred and the coven survive means that the Cullens were pretty much asking for a war at some dot . explore your neighbors before you settle into a lamia - hating domain , Cullen sept .
What Are The Odds That Carlisle Would Serve As A Doctor In Both Columbus And Milwaukee?
Carlisle Cullen travels around a lot to see that no one ever learn his deep , dark mystery : he does n’t age . In some way , it ’s the ideal life for a vampire bachelor who wants to see the world , dine on local fauna without detection and keep a low profile , but it does n’t make sense that he ’d meetEsme Platt(nee Evenson ) twice in his random travels .
After serving as her doctor in Columbus , he later economise her life and sprain her into a vampire in Milwaukee , a city to which she had fly after result her terrible first husband behind .
They Adopted A “Kid” Who Is Older Than Esme
It ’s often pointed out that Esme Cullen is the oldest of her clan , but Jasper is actually older than his own mother . He may be stuck at a untried chronological state than she is , but he was born well before she was , attain him older than … his mummy .
This is so unearthly that it ’s a storyline often poke at when someone espouse a person who is younger than his or her own tyke , making the step - parent young than the stepson or stepdaughter . It just does n’t make any sense for her to be his mum .
Carlisle Had To Be Sweet On Her When She Was 16
Most sports fan say that since Esme was 26 when Carlisle exchange her , it ’s not creepy that they first suffer when she was only 16 years old . If that ’s the type , why does n’t Carlisle change all of his patient who are passing ? He only changed this pretty young thing who allow for such a openhanded impression on him all these years .
This implies that he harbored some feelings for a prospicient time . He also think back the " happy girl " she was at 16 , not the somber young woman she ’s become , as he turns her . This attain his motives suspect as he desire herself has a teen , who was still developing and practically a baby .
They Repeatedly Enroll Their “Kids” In High School
If the Cullen patriarch and materfamilias are so supportive of their " kidskin , " why do n’t they support a good beingness for them than the perpetual gamey school they are doomed to repeat ? For anyone else , this is an endless nightmare , and the tease not being affected by everything from line spilled during fights to catamenial cycles still makes zero sense .
Why not institutionalize their nestling on student exchange programs , or encourage them to " coiffure up " or wear makeup to get in much more interesting Book of Job force ? They could always impart and start a unexampled gig when they start to wait too vernal , which would still be more interesting ( and meaningful ) than recapitulate gamey school somewhere else !
She Fell For Him (A Much Older Doctor) At Age Sixteen
Having acrush on your doctorat the tender age of 16 when you ’re still in development is one matter , but marrying that guy wire is quite another . For many people , this defend an uneven relationship due to their ages as well as his position of power , result in a creepy wedlock .
There are entire books , songs and movies write about new women who precipitate for their professor and other sometime man in positions of authority , but most of those make it decipherable that it ’s inappropriate , not something to be emulated as Esme ’s look are meant to seem in the books .
They Look Different In The Films
Like most of the people conform from novel to screenland , the Cullen family look quite unlike from their book descriptions . To be fair , Stephenie Meyer created such impossibly beautiful hoi polloi that it would be unmanageable to manifest their doppelganger , but they definitely do n’t mate on several levels .
Actor Peter Facinelli was much older than the age at which Carlisle was line , and he was supposed to be tired look , with circles beneath his eyes . While Elizabeth Reaser had Esme ’s honey - colored hairsbreadth , her face was n’t heart - shaped nor redolent of silent moving-picture show era starlets as Bella described in the book .
Carlisle Turned Her To Save Her From Harm
All four of theTwilightbooks are rivet around one huge plot point : Bella Swan ’s choice . She defeats her own death several times before the one thing that intimately cease her , her own nipper mother by her married man Edward , pretty much demolish her federal agency , leaving Edward with no choice but to turn her if he wants her to hold out .
It ’s laughable to focus so much on Bella ’s pick and not give Esme a pick in the issue . With her demise so eminent , Carlisle simply changed her without deliberate the fact that she ’d already made a choice . Some find it romantic that he saved her biography while others disaccord , arguing that he stole her option .
Esme Just Flat-Out Accepted Her New Role As Vampire Bride
After Carlisle changed Esme , we ’re expected to believe that the two hit it off quickly and lived merrily ever after without all of the drama that Edward and Bella have going on . For starters , we do n’t buy it . It ’s too clean - cut , and it ’s weird that a cleaning lady who had just attempted to off herself was so eager to enter marriage once again ( but more about that afterwards ) .
It ’s difficult to believe that Esme found being a vampire so easy to accept , let alone being the Saint Bridget of a man hundreds of geezerhood her senior who just conveniently made her into his staring bride .
